RIM has paid $612.5m to settle its BlackBerry patent dispute with NTP
RIM pays millions to avert court ordered shutdown of BlackBerry service

RIM pays $612m to settle BlackBerry case

Shutdown averted as RIM buys 'perpetual licence' from NTP

Written by Tom Sanders in California

Research in Motion has settled its patent dispute with NTP. The BlackBerry maker has agreed to pay $612.5m which includes a perpetual licence on the patents at the centre of a prolonged legal battle between the two firms.

The judge presiding over the case was expected to rule in NTP's favour and order a shutdown of the wireless email service in North America.

NTP co-founder Donal Stout said in a statement: "We are pleased to have reached an amicable settlement with RIM. We believe that the settlement is in the best interests of all parties, including the US government and all other BlackBerry users in the US."

The two parties reached an agreement in March 2005 to settle the case for $450m, but this later fell apart.

A jury found in 2002 that RIM infringed on NTP-owned patents covering an email system on mobile devices.

The US Patent and Trademark Office, meanwhile, has started to re-examine the NTP patents and has already invalidated several.

A decision on the remaining patents is expected soon, although the procedure could take years. A possible invalidation would affect the settlement.

Even though RIM faces the risk of buying a licence for patents that could be invalidated, the litigation was scaring away customers and affecting revenues, according to Kevin Burden, programme manager for mobile devices and services at analyst firm IDC

"This is probably money well spent. It's a boatload of money for patents that may not be worth anything, but it's worth it if it removes the cloud over RIM's future," Burden told vnunet.com.

See also:

reader comments

related articles

A US judge has delayed ruling on the shutdown of RIM's BlackBerry network yesterday

Judge delays BlackBerry US shutdown

Court disappointed with RIM and NTP's inability to reach a settlement 25 Feb 2006

 

RIM unveils BlackBerry patent workaround

'US mode' avoids technology covered by disputed NTP patent 10 Feb 2006

Analysts question BlackBerry patent workaround

Battle far from over, report warns 13 Feb 2006

RIM offers last minute NTP patent deal

Fourteen days left before dispute comes to court 10 Feb 2006

RIM scores BlackBerry patent victory

US Patent Office invalidates second NTP patent 23 Feb 2006

HP creates separate PDA business unit

Restructuring expected to deliver better focus on developing BlackBerry killers 14 Feb 2006

Mobile apps take centre stage at 3GSM

Making data pay is the key concern 13 Feb 2006

IT firms unite for patent protection

Cisco and Google are among the industry's names joining forces to buy intellectual property 30 Jun 2008

Samsung and InterDigital settle patent spat

Deal rumoured to be worth hundreds of millions 26 Nov 2008

Rambus awarded $133.6m in patent trial

Jury rules against Hynix, Micron and Nanya 27 Mar 2008

latest news

Ballmer highlights aims for New Year

Ballmer announces Windows 7 beta and future alliances designed to improve information sharing 08 Jan 2009

Dell quits Irish production

Vendor to slash 1,900 jobs in Limerick as it migrates assembly for EMEA customers to Poland 08 Jan 2009

Business confidence lower than 1991

Staff appointments plummeted last month as firms expect worst economic climate in 20 years 08 Jan 2009

poll

Challenging times ahead?

Challenging times ahead?

Do you think there will be a lot of channel job cuts in 2009?

Previous poll results

Paul Anderson, Trend Micro

Vendor Q&A: Paul Anderson, Trend Micro

During this Q&A session Paul Anderson, UK country manager of Trend Micro talks about the changing threat landscape and how Trend is working with resellers in 2009

In the Studio with CRN: Oracle

CRN TV catches up with Alan Hartwell, vice president of technology solutions and channels at Oracle

events

Channel Expo 2009 logo

Channel Expo 2009

The UK's top reseller exhibition will return to the NEC on 20 May 2009

CRN Fight Night 2009

The channel's only white-collar boxing event is back

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation