Polar bear

Polar bears protected, but legal caveat waters down regulatory impact

Green groups planning to use US classification of polar bear as endangered species to demand tighter carbon regulations are stymied by new rule

Written by Danny Bradbury

The US government has listed the polar bear as an endangered species after a three-year battle, but also introduced a caveat that has ignited a fresh row over the scope of the Endangered Species Act.

Secretary of the interior Dirk Kempthorne announced the classification this week, placing the polar bear under the protection of the Endangered Species Act.

This should make it much more difficult for oil companies to explore and drill for oil in large areas of the Arctic, said Kassie Siegel, executive director of the Center for Biological Diversity, who argued that most current Arctic gas and oil production facilities are located onshore.

"The government will have to prepare a recovery plan, and designate critical habitat," she said. "There will be a much higher level of environmental review. "

However, Kempthorne also announced a regulation that would exempt greenhouse gases from consideration as a threat to the polar bear. The regulation, called the interim 4d rule, was introduced "with immediate effect" by the government, but is also open for comment for 60 days. It dismisses greenhouse gases resulting from actions carried out or authorised by the federal government as having an effect on animal habitats.

"Listing the polar bear as threatened can reduce avoidable losses of polar bears," Kempthorne said. "But it should not open the door to use the ESA to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from automobiles, power plants and other sources."

The regulation would negate what environmental lobby groups had hoped would be a new requirement arising from the classification of the polar bear under the ESA. That requirement could have forced the government to consider the climactic effects of any action it authorised, including setting fuel-efficiency standards.

Seigel said the interim rule was illegal. "What they have asserted here contradicts the law. The president is supposed to carry out the law. The president does not have the right to change the wording of the law," she said.

The Centre for Biological Diversity is considering ways to challenge the introduction of the regulation.

See also:

reader comments

related articles

 

Polar bears endangered status under threat

Alaska sues US government amid fears that granting bears endangered status will harm oil industry 06 Aug 2008

Environmentalists sue White House over polar bear protection

Bush administration accused of delaying decision on polar bear's endangered status to ease sale of arctic oil drilling rights 14 Mar 2008

Alaskan governor aims to block Polar Bear protection

Governor launches legal challenge, arguing that granting Polar Bears protected status will hamper development 23 May 2008

latest news

Red Hat a good fit for Qumranet

Open source behemoth opens up Windows opportunities with acquisition of virtualisation specialist 05 Sep 2008

Infor praises partners

Software vendor outlines its channel vision at second annual EMEA partner summit in Marbella 05 Sep 2008

Version One and Accurate launch university push

Software vendors link arms to create integrated document and financial management offering for universities 05 Sep 2008

Most commented stories

poll

Stormy times ahead for PBX?

Stormy times ahead for PBX?

Will the credit crunch affect PBX takeup?

Previous poll results

In The Studio With CRN: Josh Claman, Dell

In an editorial coup for CRN, Josh Claman, vice president of EMEA channels at Dell, talks to CRN TV about the vendor's channel plans

CRN Fight Night bouts are LIVE!

ALL the bouts from CRN's first ever white collar boxing event at The Brewery in Chiswell Street, are now online in their full glory for CRN readers to watch.

events

CRN Golf Challenge 2008

CRN Channel Golf Challenge 2008

CRN's annual golfing day will this year be held on 16 September at a championship course in East Sussex

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum logo

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum

An exclusive channel conference from CRN, to be held over one action-packed day in September 2008

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories