OLPC laptop

Intel pulls out of OLPC

Chip giant withdraws support for One Laptop Per Child program due to clash of interests

Written by Rosalie Marshall

Intel has dropped its support for the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) initiative, due to fundamental differences between the organisations’ approaches and directors, Intel chairman, Craig Barrett, and OLPC’s founder, Nicholas Negroponte.

Intel spokeswoman Agnes Kwan said the differences were “impossible to reconcile” because OLPC was demanding the end of Intel’s supply of the Classmate PC, which is part of Intel’s World Ahead programme and its own attempt to provide the developing world with education through providing technology.

The Classmate PC started shipping in March, and has received orders from countries such as Brazil, Mexico and Pakistan.

Kwan said Intel could not accommodate OLPC’s request because multiple solutions are needed to meet the vast needs of children in developing countries. “Also Intel has established relationships between OEMs, suppliers and governments and these are important to sustain,” she added.

Replacing Intel’s Xeon processors in OLPC devices will be rival AMD chips.

When Intel joined OLPC’s educational programme last July, the aim was to combine the two major attempts at providing low-cost laptops for the sake of delivering global progress. At the time, both organisations committed to making each other’s laptops better.

“Both parties have long histories and experience in this area and working together will expedite these efforts for the betterment of children around the world,” Intel had said on its web site.

However Kwan said although Intel joined OLPC because both organisations shared the same vision, there were too many differences between the groups for the relationship to be sustained. Recent rumours have revealed that although Intel was donating funds to OLPC, both organisations were in competition when making sales to governments.

The split with Intel follows on from other recent difficulties faced by the OLPC organisation. The laptop, although intended to sell at $100, is now priced at nearer $200. Meanwhile in November, Negroponte admitted that verbal orders he had made with governments were not being followed by funding.

More recently OLPC’s chief technology officer, Mary Lou Jepson, has stepped down to pursue commercial interests and a Nigerian firm has demanded $20m from the non-profit organisation.

However Tony Roberts, Computer Aid International founder and director of development, said competition between groups endeavouring to bring laptops to children could bring more project success, lower priced laptops and increased numbers of manufacturers looking for ways to meet the needs of those in developing countries. Computer Aid works with a similar agenda to OLPC buts distributes refurbished computers for reuse in developing countries.

Simon Yates of Forrester Research said the marriage had been “short lived and stormy”.

“There were fundamental disagreements between OLPC and Intel that were not easy to resolve,” Yates explained, adding that the partnership was a “marriage of convenience” to overcome the bad publicity both organisations had been affected by.

Yates said that difficulties arose because OLPC had wanted Intel to abandon its own agenda in the developing world and Intel had wanted OLPC to use more processors of its own design.

Intel and OLPC are also driven by different motivations Yates said. “Intel concentrates on market opportunities and looks forward to the growth that will come from the emerging markets, whereas OLPC has a more moral defensive approach,” he added.

Negroponte’s “big personality” was also mentioned by Yates as a difficulty in the relationship. Yates concluded that Intel’s withdrawal is likely to be good for Intel, AMD and Microsoft, but bad news for OLPC. “Instead of two suppliers, OLPC now only has a single supplier.”

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Palm Foleo

IT Week's Sideways view

A look at the week's IT winners and losers - OLPC, laptops and Foleo 04 Jan 2008

 

Red Hat builds third world desktop OS

New Linux client from Red Hat is designed to work on low cost PCs 10 May 2007

How altruism could reshape IT

The One Laptop Per Child project will have a huge impact, and not just on the developing world 12 Jun 2006

Intel backs away from OLPC project

Chipmaker baulks at single-platform demand 04 Jan 2008

OLPC accuses Intel of “untenable” behaviour

Following Intel's exit from the OLPC programme the group hits back 07 Jan 2008

Intel abandons One Laptop per Child

The chip maker will develop its own machines for the developing world 04 Jan 2008

latest news

Red Hat a good fit for Qumranet

Open source behemoth opens up Windows opportunities with acquisition of virtualisation specialist 05 Sep 2008

Infor praises partners

Software vendor outlines its channel vision at second annual EMEA partner summit in Marbella 05 Sep 2008

Version One and Accurate launch university push

Software vendors link arms to create integrated document and financial management offering for universities 05 Sep 2008

Most commented stories

poll

Stormy times ahead for PBX?

Stormy times ahead for PBX?

Will the credit crunch affect PBX takeup?

Previous poll results

In The Studio With CRN: Josh Claman, Dell

In an editorial coup for CRN, Josh Claman, vice president of EMEA channels at Dell, talks to CRN TV about the vendor's channel plans

CRN Fight Night bouts are LIVE!

ALL the bouts from CRN's first ever white collar boxing event at The Brewery in Chiswell Street, are now online in their full glory for CRN readers to watch.

events

CRN Golf Challenge 2008

CRN Channel Golf Challenge 2008

CRN's annual golfing day will this year be held on 16 September at a championship course in East Sussex

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum logo

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum

An exclusive channel conference from CRN, to be held over one action-packed day in September 2008

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories