Anti-virus vendors trade insults over Vista

McAfee hits back at Sophos snipe

Written by Matt Chapman

A row has broken out between rival anti-virus companies about their readiness to provide protection for Microsoft's new operating system.

McAfee and Symantec have both complained that without access to the 64-bit code for Windows Vista they won't be able to develop products for it.

Sophos waded into the row on Monday when it claimed that both McAfee and Symantec should have prepared better for the launch of Vista.

"Symantec and McAfee may be struggling with host intrusion prevention (HIPS) because they haven't coded their solutions with high-spec Vista in mind," said Richard Jacobs, chief technology officer at Sophos.

"Additionally, Sophos is building its technology by making use of supported Microsoft interfaces rather than by trying to subvert them. That's why we're ready for 64-bit Vista, and others aren't."

McAfee has hit back at those claims and has dubbed Sophos a single-product vendor that doesn't face the same challenges.

"It is crucial that readers understand the difference between McAfee and those companies that focus on anti-virus software alone," said Siobhan MacDermott, VP of worldwide corporate communications at McAfee.

"Single-product vendors, like Sophos, may well not have an issue with Microsoft."

McAfee pointed to comments made by Gartner security analyst Neil MacDonald, who backed up McAfee's claims that Sophos is not affected in the same way as its rivals.

MacDonald said that Sophos "didn't have the same capabilities" and wouldn't be affected in the same way as the other companies.

McAfee warned Microsoft that its "flawed logic" would only result in making computers more vulnerable to viruses and other attacks.

"To protect customers from the bad guys, you don't lock out the good guys," said MacDermott. "Internet security is everyone's business, and we hope that Microsoft will return to the collaborative approach that has served customers well in the past."

The problem is caused by Microsoft's Patchguard prevention system, which Symantec and McAfee claim has locked them out of the Vista operating system kernel and is anti-competitive.

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Retail

Tesco to sell low-cost software

Office suite, security, photo-editor and DVD burner titles for £20 or less 02 Oct 2006

 

New security suite from Trend

Protection against rootkits, phishing, spam and identity theft, company claims 19 Sep 2006

Microsoft releases Vista RC1 download

Latest version now available to five million people 05 Sep 2006

Wireless USB finally ready, but no support from Microsoft

Products supporting the standard out by Christmas but with no driver support 28 Sep 2006

Hackers defeat US homeland security

Simulated attacks highlight weaknesses in cyberspace 14 Sep 2006

McAfee repeats Wifi security warning

WPA vulnerable unless you take care, insists security firm after accusations of scaremongering 09 Aug 2006

Sophos releases integrated security package

Bundles protection against adware, malware and spyware 12 Jun 2006

Antivirus struggles on 64-bit Vista

35 per cent of 64-bit Vitsa antivirus software receives failing grade 03 Aug 2007

Intel beefs up security in vPro

Latest version of the PC platform includes new virtualisation security and improved AMT capabilities 29 Aug 2007

Thieves to target new technologies

New surveys find that tech-savvy criminals are seeking new targets 29 Nov 2007

latest news

Microsoft swoops amid fears over piracy rise

Software giant claims struggling VARs are under pressure to cut corners 18 Jul 2008

Sony targets B2B glory

IT giant targets lap-top market 18 Jul 2008

EMEA drives IBM revenue rise

IT behemoth sees EMEA revenues rise by a fifth as it celebrates "outstanding " quarter 18 Jul 2008

poll

Fuel for thought?

Fuel for thought?

Is Ingram right to pass on the rising cost of fuel through a freight charge?

Previous poll results

In The Studio With CRN: Josh Claman, Dell

In an editorial coup for CRN, Josh Claman, vice president of EMEA channels at Dell, talks to CRN TV about the vendor's channel plans

CRN Fight Night bouts are LIVE!

ALL the bouts from CRN's first ever white collar boxing event at The Brewery in Chiswell Street, are now online in their full glory for CRN readers to watch.

events

CRN Golf Challenge 2008

CRN Channel Golf Challenge 2008

CRN's annual golfing day will this year be held on 16 September at a championship course in East Sussex

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum logo

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum

An exclusive channel conference from CRN, to be held over one action-packed day in September 2008

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories