PC World pulled up over advert

What constitutes a 'huge' hard drive?

Written by Matt Chapman

PC World has been wrapped on the knuckles for misleading viewers with one of its adverts.

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) said the TV ad for the £349 Advent 7000A Intel Celeron M laptop had breached the CAP broadcast codes on misleading advertising, implications and qualifications.

"A huge 40GB hard drive, great for watching DVDs, movies... It's our lowest ever priced laptop. You'll find it hard to beat even on the internet, and I guarantee they won't be in stock for much longer at this price..." said the salesman in the advert.

The advert received six complaints - three from viewers who said it had sold out in shops and online while the ad was still playing; one from a buyer who was offered the laptop as part of a more expensive package; and two who questioned whether the "huge 40GB hard drive" wasn't standard for a laptop.

The ASA upheld two of the complaints and dismissed the other.

"The number of laptops was not sufficient to meet demand for such a low priced item. We therefore considered PC World did not have adequate stock," said the ruling.

PC World tried to argue that the claim over the size of the hard drive was subjective and the advert was supposed to illustrate that there had been no cost cutting on such an inexpensive laptop.

However, the ASA said it understood that a 40GB drive was fairly standard for laptops.

"We appreciated the intention had been to show the laptop was not underpowered, but by claiming the hard drive was 'huge' the ad had exaggerated the technical specifications that would normally be expected with such a computer," the ruling stated.

However, the ASA found that the complainant who was offered the laptop only as part of a more expensive bundle was misled by shop staff rather than the advert itself.

"We noted the laptops were available to buy separately, and not as part of a package," said the ASA's statement.

"It was unfortunate that the viewer was given the wrong information, but it appeared to have been an isolated incident. We considered the ad had not breached the Code on this point."

The ASA ruling said that the advert should not be shown again in its current form.

See also:

reader comments

related articles

 

Eidos rapped by ASA

Kane and Lynch ad too graphic 10 Apr 2008

PC World pulled up over PlayStation ad

ASA raps retailer for misleading claims 13 May 2008

Orange let off the hook over Rainbow ad

'Unlimited' does not have to mean 'unlimited', says ASA 30 Apr 2008

latest news

Ballmer highlights aims for New Year

Ballmer announces Windows 7 beta and future alliances designed to improve information sharing 08 Jan 2009

Active Storage completes UK Jigsaw

Jigsaw unveiled as Raid vendor's first non-US Platinum partner as it launches in Europe 08 Jan 2009

Dell quits Irish production

Vendor to slash 1,900 jobs in Limerick as it migrates assembly for EMEA customers to Poland 08 Jan 2009

poll

Challenging times ahead?

Challenging times ahead?

Do you think there will be a lot of channel job cuts in 2009?

Previous poll results

Paul Anderson, Trend Micro

Vendor Q&A: Paul Anderson, Trend Micro

During this Q&A session Paul Anderson, UK country manager of Trend Micro talks about the changing threat landscape and how Trend is working with resellers in 2009

Sara Yirrell and Rick Wallis

Vendor Q&A: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

In this exclusive vendor Q&A, Rick Wallis, UK sales director at NEC Computers talks to CRN editor Sara Yirrell about his firm’s plans for the channel.

events

Channel Expo 2009 logo

Channel Expo 2009

The UK's top reseller exhibition will return to the NEC on 20 May 2009

CRN Fight Night 2009

The channel's only white-collar boxing event is back

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation