Watchdog raps Disney over mobile game charges

'Cars' game giving customers the run around

Written by Ian Williams

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has taken Disney Mobile to task over unsuitable and possibly misleading adverts for two mobile phone games on the back of a Disney Store brochure. 

A customer complained that the ads did not make clear the full costs of the games, and were irresponsible because they appealed to children who could download the games without adult permission.

The UK advertising watchdog investigated the matter and has ruled for the complainant.

Customers were invited to send an SMS using the short code in the ad, and received a text message back with a link to the relevant operator portal. This contained information on the games, the price and the terms and conditions.

Text at the side of both ads stated: 'Standard operator text charges apply. This is not a subscription service'.

But the ASA concluded that the ads "should have either included the full cost of downloading the games, or explained clearly that the cost referred to in the ads was the cost of gathering information about the games and that a further charge would apply to get the games on your phone".

The ASA ruling stated: "Although we acknowledged that the brochure was intended for adults, we considered that, because of the type of products being offered and because it featured children playing with the toys, the brochure was likely to be of interest to children.

"We concluded that, because the total cost of downloading the games was in excess of £3, and children who tried to download the games might not have asked adult permission, or fully understood the costs incurred to get the games, the ads were unsuitable for publication in the Disney Store brochure."

Disney said that it believed the price for purchase was clearly stated and that the ads were not misleading. The company does not intend to use the ads again and will aim to make future ads clearer to avoid any potential confusion.

See also:

reader comments

related articles

IVA providers slammed by ads watchdog

Advertising Standards Authority finds IVA factory ads miselading  12 Apr 2007

 

Xbox 360 ad banned in the UK

Microsoft advert slapped for 'glamorising street racing' 04 Apr 2007

DRM lobby scrambles to block HD DVD crack

Legal campaign only succeeds in further publicising the exploit 02 May 2007

EA takes stake in China games firm

World of Warcraft operator grabs 15 per cent of The9 23 May 2007

UK mobile content market to 'skyrocket'

Operators look forward to multi-billion dollar industry 30 May 2007

Eidos rapped by ASA

Kane and Lynch ad too graphic 10 Apr 2008

ASA critical of Dell advert

Delivery charge added significantly to price of laptop 02 Jun 2008

Virgin Media rapped over Setanta ad

Sky disputes 'cheapest' claim 14 May 2008

latest news

Exclusive: Bell Micro EMEA confims job cuts

Distributor looking to make cost savings of 10 per cent across the business 21 Nov 2008

Avnet looks forward to 2009

Chief executive Roy Vallee reveals why the distributor is confident of riding out the storm 21 Nov 2008

PC growth forecasts slashed by two-thirds

Market watcher downgrades 2009 PC growth expectations from 11.9 to 4.3 per cent 21 Nov 2008

poll

Securing the future

Securing the future

Does the security channel need a governing body?

Previous poll results

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

During this Q&A session Rick Wallis, UK Sales Director at NEC Computers, talks about the firm’s reasons for committing to a 100 per cent channel strategy

In the Studio with CRN: Oracle

CRN TV catches up with Alan Hartwell, vice president of technology solutions and channels at Oracle

events

Channel Expo 2009 logo

Channel Expo 2009

The UK's top reseller exhibition will return to the NEC on 20 May 2009

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation