Apple

UK watchdog clears Apple ads

'I'm a Mac, I'm a PC' campaign not misleading, rules ASA

Written by Ian Williams

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has cleared Apple's 'I'm a Mac, I'm a PC' ad campaign starring comedians David Mitchell and Robert Webb after several complaints from viewers. 

Apple's national press campaign for the Apple Mac suggested that PCs were vulnerable to viruses and often needed to be restarted.

The ASA received 14 complaints about the ads, most of which claimed that they were potentially misleading.

Most of the complainants pointed out that viruses attack software and operating systems, not hardware, and that a PC could use a variety of software and operating systems, some of which contracted similar low numbers of viruses as Mac OS X.

The complainants questioned whether the ads misleadingly implied that all PCs, regardless of the software or operating system, were vulnerable to crashing, would contract a number of viruses and would frequently need to be restarted.

Eight of the 14 complainants questioned whether the claim 'I run Mac OS X so you don't have to worry about the viruses and spyware that PCs do' was misleading and irresponsible.

The implication, according to the complaints, was that Mac computers could not be infected by viruses and therefore did not require virus protection.

Apple said that the ads were based on PCs that ran Microsoft Windows, which it believed were more vulnerable to crashing, would contract more viruses and would need to be restarted more frequently than Macs.

Apple added that the ads were targeted at the home consumer, not the technology professional.

The company asserted that almost 97 per cent of home PCs, used for non-commercial purposes, run on a version of Windows and that the claims were accurate for the target audience.

The ASA has agreed with Apple's stance that it is understood that Macs are able to run Microsoft Windows but also noted that it was not the principal operating system they used, or came packaged with, and did not require Microsoft Windows to operate.

The watchdog considered that the claims in the ads would be understood to refer to Macs that run Apple software and PCs that run Microsoft Windows.

Apple was therefore not in breach of clauses concerning 'Responsible advertising', 'Truthfulness' or 'Other comparisons' as suggested by the complaints.

Apple confirmed that the ads are no longer in use and that the firm has no plans to run them again.

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Apple

Apple woos kids with Summer Camps

Free workshops for eight to 12 year-olds 11 Jun 2007

 

YouTube coming to Apple TV

Plug-in for set-top box scheduled for June 31 May 2007

Apple issues 13 security fixes

Problems with CoreGraphics, Fetchmail, iChat and mDNSResponder 25 May 2007

Apple brings Safari to Windows

'The fastest browser on Windows,' Jobs claims 12 Jun 2007

Security flaw hits Safari on Windows

Researcher demolishes Apple's security claims 12 Jun 2007

Virgin Media rapped over Setanta ad

Sky disputes 'cheapest' claim 14 May 2008

Orange let off the hook over Rainbow ad

'Unlimited' does not have to mean 'unlimited', says ASA 30 Apr 2008

Motorola accused of 'glamorising' violence

But ASA rules Razr 2 adverts are not offensive 06 Feb 2008

latest news

Exclusive: Bell Micro EMEA confims job cuts

Distributor looking to make cost savings of 10 per cent across the business 21 Nov 2008

Avnet looks forward to 2009

Chief executive Roy Vallee reveals why the distributor is confident of riding out the storm 21 Nov 2008

PC growth forecasts slashed by two-thirds

Market watcher downgrades 2009 PC growth expectations from 11.9 to 4.3 per cent 21 Nov 2008

poll

Securing the future

Securing the future

Does the security channel need a governing body?

Previous poll results

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

During this Q&A session Rick Wallis, UK Sales Director at NEC Computers, talks about the firm’s reasons for committing to a 100 per cent channel strategy

In the Studio with CRN: Oracle

CRN TV catches up with Alan Hartwell, vice president of technology solutions and channels at Oracle

events

Channel Expo 2009 logo

Channel Expo 2009

The UK's top reseller exhibition will return to the NEC on 20 May 2009

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation