Patent seal
New legislation seeks to limit the damages for patent infringement

Inventors protest at US patent bill

Proposed reform would 'stifle innovation'

Written by Iain Thomson

Protests have begun over a reform of the patent laws being considered by the US government.

Dean Kamen, inventor of the Segway and holder of 440 patents, was one of a group of inventors who have testified to the US Senate against the proposed law.

The legislation seeks to limit the damages for patent infringement, and allow patents to be challenged more easily after they have been issued.

The bill is being supported by Microsoft and Cisco, which claim that they are at the mercy of companies that own a patent on small portions of much larger applications and use this to reap substantial pay outs.

But Kamen warned that the legislation, if passed, would be disproportionately harmful to inventors.

"You do not shut down the national pastime of baseball because some players are using steroids," Kamen told the San José Mercury News.

"You can go after 'trolls' and other bad actors without unintended consequences that are harmful."

The bill has already passed the US House of Representatives and is being considered by the Senate.

The legislation has now provoked a number of small companies to band together as the Innovation Alliance to oppose its progress.

"We know that 40 per cent of patents are held by small business," said Innovation Alliance spokeswoman Susan Mora.

"We can only guess at the number of patents currently in the coffers of the largest corporations that started with discoveries made by individual inventors, small businesses and America's publicly funded universities.

"These are the drivers of innovation. To put this new cost on innovators so that patent infringers can reduce their supposedly soaring litigation costs is unconscionable."

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Mega patent claim targets media firms

Fifteen firms join Apple in row over music list building system 14 Sep 2007

 

NTP sues several US wireless firms

Latest patent battle seeks royalty payments for email infringements 12 Sep 2007

UK and US patent offices to fast-track applications

Global patent highway also includes Japan 06 Sep 2007

US to change multi-patent rules

One invention, one claim 20 Aug 2007

Nokia issues call to innovators

Competition to boost global development on Nokia platforms 19 Sep 2008

IT giants hook up to fight patent litigation

Group buys up patents to avoid legal woes 01 Jul 2008

Apple turns to British 'iPod inventor'

Kane Kramer filed a patent nearly 30 years ago 09 Sep 2008

latest news

Civica wins Harrow Council contract

LAR beats tough competition through Catalist tender to revamp council's parking system 09 Jan 2009

Novell to shuffle EMEA executive pack

Linux vendor shifts partner programme responsibilities to marketing organisation 09 Jan 2009

Ballmer highlights aims for New Year

Ballmer announces Windows 7 beta and future alliances designed to improve information sharing 08 Jan 2009

poll

Challenging times ahead?

Challenging times ahead?

Do you think there will be a lot of channel job cuts in 2009?

Previous poll results

Paul Anderson, Trend Micro

Vendor Q&A: Paul Anderson, Trend Micro

During this Q&A session Paul Anderson, UK country manager of Trend Micro talks about the changing threat landscape and how Trend is working with resellers in 2009

Sara Yirrell and Rick Wallis

Vendor Q&A: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

In this exclusive vendor Q&A, Rick Wallis, UK sales director at NEC Computers talks to CRN editor Sara Yirrell about his firm’s plans for the channel.

events

Channel Expo 2009 logo

Channel Expo 2009

The UK's top reseller exhibition will return to the NEC on 20 May 2009

CRN Fight Night 2009

The channel's only white-collar boxing event is back

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation