Steve Ballmer
Steve Ballmer believes that people who use Red Hat have an obligation to compensate Microsoft

Microsoft aims patent guns at Red Hat

'You're violating our IP, now pay up,' Ballmer theatens

Written by Tom Sanders in California

Microsoft chief executive Steve Ballmer has warned users of Red Hat Linux that they will have to pay Microsoft for its intellectual property.

"People who use Red Hat, at least with respect to our intellectual property, in a sense have an obligation to compensate us," Ballmer said last week at a company event in London discussing online services in the UK.

A video report of Ballmer's speech (registration required) was posted on Mydeo over the weekend.

Red Hat has repeatedly stated that it will not engage in a patent licensing deal similar to the Novell-Microsoft partnership, referring to its as an 'innovation tax'.

Microsoft has been the second most aggressive party in pursuing alleged intellectual property claims against Linux and open source in general.

The firm ranks behind SCO, which failed in its attempt to prove that it owns the intellectual property to Linux and now faces bankruptcy.

Microsoft inked a partnership with Novell last year in which Novell agreed to license Microsoft's intellectual property in exchange for a patent pledge to users of Novell's SuSE Linux.

Ballmer praised Novell at the UK event for valuing intellectual property, and suggested that open source vendors will be forced to strike similar deals with other patent holders.

He predicted that firms like Eolas will soon come after open source vendors or users. Microsoft paid $521m to settle a patent claim by Eolas in August.

"Every time an Eolas comes to Microsoft and says: 'Pay us,' I expect they eventually would like to go to the open source world [as well]," said Ballmer.

"Getting an intellectual property interoperability framework between the two worlds, I think, is important."

Microsoft supported the (rejected) European software patent directive, which would have allowed software patents to be filed within the EU.

Software patents are permitted in the US today. But poor oversight and quality control at the US Patent and Trademark Office allow for many 'bad' patents to be awarded.

Patent critics argue that software does not need long term protection by patents. Development costs of software innovations require fewer investments than for mechanical or pharmaceutical innovations.

Today's cutting edge innovations, furthermore, are reduced to commodities in a matter of a few months or years.

Repeating his call for software patents, Ballmer argued for a limited reform of the US patent system.

"The thing I worry about is that people will want to throw the baby out with the bath water and say: 'Let's just get rid of this.' That would be a terrible thing for innovation in companies large and small," he said.

"Reform makes sense, but we should make sure that it facilitates innovation in our industry as well as others."

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Bill Gates and Linux

Linux group calls Microsoft's bluff

Show us the patents 04 Oct 2007

 

US legal case tests GPL's mettle

Is the open source licence a business contract or a copyright notice? 24 Sep 2007

Inventors protest at US patent bill

Proposed reform would 'stifle innovation' 21 Sep 2007

Nasdaq poised to delist SCO Group

The meltdown continues 20 Sep 2007

Mega patent claim targets media firms

Fifteen firms join Apple in row over music list building system 14 Sep 2007

NTP sues several US wireless firms

Latest patent battle seeks royalty payments for email infringements 12 Sep 2007

UK and US patent offices to fast-track applications

Global patent highway also includes Japan 06 Sep 2007

Government considers file-sharing law

Letters from ISPs will not stop illegal uploads and downloads of music and movies, it says 31 Jul 2008

Microsoft brings back automatic ActiveX

Eolas settlement allows interactive websites to function without user clicks 12 Nov 2007

US patent office speeds appeals process

Another step in the long road to patent reform 10 Jun 2008

latest news

Acer grabs top spot in EMEA PC market

HP ousted as top dog in EMEA as Acer continues its bid for world domination 15 Oct 2008

Eurodata boosts services with Transam

VAR leaps into SAM, SaaS and email archiving markets with acquisition 15 Oct 2008

Salmon tickled pink over Microsoft accolade

Integrator secures Microsoft Gold Partner status in first year of partnership 15 Oct 2008

poll

Education gap?

Education gap?

Is there still business up for grabs in the education space?

Previous poll results

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

During this Q&A session Rick Wallis, UK Sales Director at NEC Computers, talks about the firm’s reasons for committing to a 100 per cent channel strategy

In The Studio with CRN: Dave Poskett, HP

CRN TV catches up with Dave Poskett, director of Solutions Partner Organisation for the UK & Ireland at HP

events

Channel Awards logo

CRN Channel Awards 2008

The Channel Awards recognise excellence and exceptional performance from businesses and individuals in the UK technology channel

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation