Government ignores Lords advice on online crime

Downing Street accused of 'head in the sand' approach

Written by Iain Thomson

The UK government has overwhelmingly rejected the recommendations on internet security suggested by the Lords Science and Technology Committee, causing fury among peers.

The peers recommended a police enforcement agency for online crime, making banks officially responsible for losses as an incentive to address online security issues, and setting up a Kitemark to be awarded to secure ISPs.

However, the government dismissed most of the report's findings. "The government recognises the dangers of complacency against this background of continuing success," it said in a statement (PDF).

"Although the number and sophistication of security threats has risen over recent years the government believes that this has to be viewed in the context of the dramatic increase in internet usage.

"As such, we would [deny] the suggestion that the public has lost confidence in the internet and that lawlessness is rife."

The Earl of Erroll, an influential member of the Committee, said: " Throughout our inquiry we tried to look ahead 10 years at what the internet might be like, taking into account the emerging risks and challenges today. That is why our recommendations concentrated on incentives.

"We must ensure that everyone is motivated to improve security. Unfortunately, the government dismissed every recommendation out of hand, and its approach seems to consist solely of putting its head in the sand."

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Tory MP John Redwood

Redwood urges Tories to scrap IR35

Free contractors to do business, says MP 21 Aug 2007

 

Education and coordination required to combat cyber crime

House of Lords report sparks security debate 10 Aug 2007

Nasa hacker McKinnon appeals to the House of Lords

Last stop before the European Court of Human Rights? 02 Aug 2007

Lords likely to recommend cyber-crime legislation

Long term study due to report in July 24 Apr 2007

Police track deleted UK government emails

US software used in cash-for-peerage investigation 12 Jul 2006

Lords react angrily to government response

The House of Lords is not happy with the government's response to its calls for more net security 01 Nov 2007

Government 'ignores' internet security issues

Lords committee makes 23 recommendations to instill public confidence in the internet 30 Oct 2007

Government ignoring web threats, say angry lords

Personal internet security recommendations "dismissed our of hand" 30 Oct 2007

latest news

Barlow leaves Computacenter

Former Equanet chief said to be looking for next channel opportunity after parting company with corporate reseller 06 Oct 2008

BT reveals ambitious plans for services arm

Telecoms giant looks to double turnover for renamed services division 06 Oct 2008

Veeam targets VMware channel

VMware management tools vendor plans to recruit 50 partners after touching down in UK 06 Oct 2008

poll

To trade or not to trade?

To trade or not to trade?

Is the rise in card-not-present fraud discouraging you from trading online?

Previous poll results

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

Vendor Q&A Session: Rick Wallis, NEC Computers

During this Q&A session Rick Wallis, UK Sales Director at NEC Computers, talks about the firm’s reasons for committing to a 100 per cent channel strategy

In The Studio with CRN: Dave Poskett, HP

CRN TV catches up with Dave Poskett, director of Solutions Partner Organisation for the UK & Ireland at HP

events

Channel Awards logo

CRN Channel Awards 2008

The Channel Awards recognise excellence and exceptional performance from businesses and individuals in the UK technology channel

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Primary Navigation