Motorola accused of 'glamorising' violence

But ASA rules Razr 2 adverts are not offensive

Written by Robert Jaques

Motorola has been accused of posting "offensive and irresponsible" adverts that glamorise knife-related violence.

The Advertising Standards Agency received complaints after the mobile firm ran a national press ad and three posters for its Razr 2 handset.

The press ad appeared in The Daily Telegraph and showed a woman wearing PVC clothes.

She was styled like a Samurai warrior and was standing with her hands clasped in front of her, holding a mobile phone at an angle so that it resembled a knife.

The text accompanying the advert stated: 'Music to your ears. External music controls. Stereo Bluetooth Razr 2. Sharper than ever.' The '2' was shaped like a knife slash.

The first poster showed a man and woman facing each other posing in 'fighting' positions. They were both wearing PVC clothes and held mobile phones at an angle, so that they resembled knives.

The man wore headphones and had a tattoo on his upper arm shaped in the form of a knife slash resembling the number two.

A second poster showed the same man holding a mobile phone at an angle so that it resembled a knife. He wore headphones and his tattoo was visible. He posed in a stance as if he were ready to fight.

A third poster, on London Underground escalator panels, showed a woman wearing PVC clothes, holding a mobile phone at an angle so that it resembled a knife.

Defending itself against the criticisms Motorola said that the ads were part of a broader Razr 2 campaign which featured highly stylised fantasy characters engaged in fluid dance movements, rather than confrontations.

The company added that the highly stylised images were designed not to be realistic or to present the characters as "aspirational".

In addition the company argued that the current campaign highlighted and reinforced previous marketing messages for the Razr phone, relating to the 'razor' thinness and the fact that the phone represented a device that is at the cutting edge of technology.

"Motorola believed the ads did not condone or glorify knife violence because they made no reference to knives or violence and the campaign was not about depicting or encouraging physical harm," said the ASA in its ruling.

"It said it was clear that the fantasy characters in the ads were holding mobile phones, not knives. It added that the man's tattoo was not intended to be a depiction of a knife slash and clearly represented the signature '2' from the Razr 2 logo."

After considering the evidence the ASA backed Motorola and refused to uphold the complaints.

The watchdog considered that most readers would appreciate that the ads were promoting the Razr 2 and would understand the link between the image of the phone, which when held at an angle resembled a razor, and the name of the product.

"We agreed that the characters were highly stylised but disagreed with Motorola that the ads made no reference to knives. Although no direct reference was made the intended link that the product resembled a razor, a knife-like object, was clear," the ASA stated.

"Although the models used in the ads were glamorous and the phone was being advertised as a razor-like product we did not think the ads either glamorised or condoned real violence.

"The characters looked fantastical and were not representative of today's culture. We considered that most readers would not see the images as promoting violence or giving the message that violence was to be, in any way, condoned.

"We concluded that the ads were not irresponsible and were unlikely to cause serious or widespread offence."

See also:

reader comments

related articles

Apple iPhone

New 16GB iPhone will be international

Apple confirms UK release 06 Feb 2008

 

LG launches KF510 slider phone

Early start on Mobile World Congress 05 Feb 2008

Nokia opens the door on 'Ovi'

Nokia heads into services arena with new Ovi platform 11 Sep 2007

O2 and 3 combine mobile video networks

New EyeVibe combines SeeMeTV and LookAtMe 04 Feb 2008

Drivers ignoring mobile phone laws

Tougher penalties not working 01 Feb 2008

Eidos rapped by ASA

Kane and Lynch ad too graphic 10 Apr 2008

Violent GTA IV ad escapes censure

ASA sides with Rockstar after viewer complaints 30 Jul 2008

Nintendo beats gun and knife ad rap

Resident Evil IV advert cleared of being 'offensive and tasteless' 24 Oct 2007

latest news

Red Hat a good fit for Qumranet

Open source behemoth opens up Windows opportunities with acquisition of virtualisation specialist 05 Sep 2008

Infor praises partners

Software vendor outlines its channel vision at second annual EMEA partner summit in Marbella 05 Sep 2008

Version One and Accurate launch university push

Software vendors link arms to create integrated document and financial management offering for universities 05 Sep 2008

Most commented stories

poll

Stormy times ahead for PBX?

Stormy times ahead for PBX?

Will the credit crunch affect PBX takeup?

Previous poll results

In The Studio With CRN: Josh Claman, Dell

In an editorial coup for CRN, Josh Claman, vice president of EMEA channels at Dell, talks to CRN TV about the vendor's channel plans

CRN Fight Night bouts are LIVE!

ALL the bouts from CRN's first ever white collar boxing event at The Brewery in Chiswell Street, are now online in their full glory for CRN readers to watch.

events

CRN Golf Challenge 2008

CRN Channel Golf Challenge 2008

CRN's annual golfing day will this year be held on 16 September at a championship course in East Sussex

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum logo

CRN Reseller Leadership Forum

An exclusive channel conference from CRN, to be held over one action-packed day in September 2008

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories