CISPE files complaint over EU Commission delay on Broadcom-VMware deal
The organisation says the “systemic issue” amounts to “a denial of justice for those hit by these bullyboy tactics”
CISPE has filed a complaint with the European Ombudsman, an independent watchdog that examines how EU institutions handle decisions, over the time taken to publish the European Commission’s reasoning for approving Broadcom’s acquisition of VMware.
The trade association argues that the Commission allowed the takeover on 12th July 2023 but took 672 days to publish its rationale.
It claims that, during that time, the US vendor imposed a series of sharp price increases and what the CISPE calls “new, unfair software licensing terms that pulled the rug from under the feet of thousands of European organisations dependent on VMware’s virtualisation software.”
The organisation says that this delay prevented European companies from being able to appeal against the decision which in its view, amounted to a denial of justice for those hit by what it described as “bullyboy tactics.”
The Commission’s defence, published in The Financial Times, is that it “has the duty to protect business secrets and other confidential information of companies involved in merger procedures.”
According to CISPE, this delay risks normalising the behaviour displayed by Broadcom, making it harder for customers to overturn or break free of their contracts.
The trade association says this issue goes beyond this case and is becoming a systemic issue with the Commission, as lags of two years or more have allegedly been increasingly common regarding mergers, citing the delay of 1,463 days for the non-confidential publication of Imerys’ buyout of certain assets of Alteo.
CISPE is calling for tighter deadlines, proposing a maximum of two months between a deal decision and the publication of its non-confidential version.
“They say justice delayed is justice denied, and for too long the Commission has allowed delays in publishing its decisions to play into the hands of those that wish to impose unfair terms, prices and behaviours on European customers,” said CISPE.
This follows its recent appeal before the General Court of the EU against the European Commission's decision to approve Broadcom's acquisition of VMware, with the organisation seeking to annul the decision.
It said that the Brussels executive arm allegedly did not impose any conditions on Broadcom to prevent excessive market concentration, nor did it take any actions to mitigate the risk of abuse of a dominant position.
In a statement sent to CRN at the time, a spokesperson from Broadcom said the vendor “strongly disagrees with these allegations.”
“The European Commission, along with twelve other jurisdictions around the world, approved our acquisition of VMware following a thorough merger review process, and we will uphold the commitments made to the Commission at that time,” the spokesperson added.
In June, a report by the European Cloud Competition Observatory (ECCO) group also highlighted that Broadcom’s overall business model was “legally and ethically flawed.”
This comes as cloud computing services are under deep scrutiny in the EU.
Last month, the European Commission opened three market investigations into cloud computing services to assess whether Amazon and Microsoft should be designated as “gatekeepers” for their cloud computing services, despite not meeting the DMA’s size, user number, and market position thresholds.