Has cybersecurity reached peak vendor? Why MSPs are saying less is more
With more than 6,500 cybersecurity vendors competing for attention, MSPs are rethinking their crowded security stacks. But do fewer vendors really mean better protection?
It’s the final day of CRN’s global Cybersecurity Week 2026 content project.
Yes, the cybersecurity industry has a solution for everything. For MSPs though, that might be part of the problem.
Analyst firm Omdia estimates there are more than 6,500 cybersecurity vendors operating globally, all competing for a share of the security market. For MSPs already juggling multiple products, platforms and customer environments, that’s an overwhelming amount of noise to cut through.
It’s not even a case of choosing between vendors – it’s managing the growing number of tools customers have accumulated, often with overlapping capabilities, separate management consoles and little integration between them.
“Most of the organisations we take on have somewhere between eight and twelve security products already running, and almost none of them has anybody whose job it is to see across all of them at once,” said Alex Martin, managing director at MSP Reliance Cyber.
“The individual tools usually work but nobody owns the space between them, and that is exactly where an attacker operates.”
So rather than continually adding products to address new threats, could the answer to better cybersecurity actually be fewer tools?
The channel: a crowded market, consolidating at the top
Despite the thousands of vendors competing in cybersecurity, Omdia estimates that the top 20 account for more than 70 percent of technology spending.
Matthew Ball, chief analyst at Omdia, said the overall vendor population remains relatively stable despite ongoing acquisitions and business failures. New suppliers continually emerge to address new threats and expanding attack surfaces.
“Cybersecurity, by its nature, is complex,” he said. AI is giving attackers greater skills and scale, while organisations have more to protect.
Meanwhile, established vendors are acquiring specialist providers and expanding into adjacent security categories, creating broader platforms designed to replace multiple point products.
Omdia’s research suggests partners typically want to work with just two to four strategic vendors. But selecting those relationships involves much more than comparing products.
Ball said MSPs have finite resources to dedicate to vendor training and partner programmes, making it impractical to maintain large numbers of strategic relationships. Integration, vendor roadmaps, partner programmes and personal relationships therefore all influence the decision.
Consolidate the workflow, not necessarily the tools
For Chris Gilmour, CTO at Axians UK, the challenge isn’t the number of cybersecurity products available, but how effectively organisations manage the technologies they already own.
“Security teams need fewer dashboards, better visibility and more actionable intelligence rather than simply more tools,” he said.
Axians is rationalising its vendor portfolio where appropriate, but Gilmour said consolidation should never become an objective in itself.
“In my experience a well-integrated security architecture built on good technologies will almost always outperform a collection of so called ‘best-of-breed’ solutions that have been poorly integrated.”
Alex Wheelhouse, head of product engineering at Reliance Cyber, draws a distinction between consolidating security operations and consolidating the underlying controls.
“Consolidate the data and the workflow. Keep best of breed at the control layer. That is the whole answer, and it is a distinction a lot of the industry conversation misses.”
His team has spent three years building services around one security operations platform, bringing evidence together so analysts can investigate incidents without switching between multiple systems.
Crucially, that doesn’t mean relying on one vendor for every security capability. Endpoint protection, identity and cloud security can remain with specialist suppliers, while detection, investigation and response are brought together in a single operational environment.
That approach also avoids unnecessary duplication. Wheelhouse describes using APIs to retrieve information from cloud security products when needed, rather than ingesting and storing all their telemetry.
The economics of fewer vendors
For MSPs, simplification can also transform the economics of managed security. However, the biggest savings may have little to do with licence prices.
“Licence cost does not really fall. You stop paying five vendors and start paying two, usually more to each of them,” said Martin.
Instead, the benefits come from reduced engineering effort, faster onboarding and improved analyst productivity. He points to a recent scoping exercise where covering applications through the identity layer, rather than creating individual connectors, roughly halved the estimated onboarding effort.
“That is the same coverage for about half the engineering days.”
For MSPs operating on tight margins, the ability to support additional customers without proportionately increasing headcount is potentially far more valuable than a discounted software bundle.
The danger of putting everything in one basket
Of course, consolidation can create new risks.
Ball warns that no single vendor can continually develop every capability needed to address emerging threats. And depending too heavily on one supplier can leave partners exposed to outages, pricing changes or commercial decisions outside their control.
Wheelhouse identifies another, less obvious problem: technical teams can become so accustomed to one platform that they lose the skills needed to operate alternatives. To counter this, Reliance Cyber retains independent security controls, contractual rights to extract data and detection content, and expertise across multiple technologies.
“The thing that actually protects you is being able to leave. Not leaving, being able to,” said Wheelhouse.
Winning a place in the MSP stack
The current complexity presents a challenge for vendors attempting to break into established MSP portfolios.
“The volume of vendor outreach has definitely increased, and most security leaders are overwhelmed by it. Every vendor claims to be AI-powered, every platform claims to consolidate the stack, and every product claims to be best-of-breed. Cutting through that noise is becoming increasingly difficult,” said Gilmour.
Martin is equally frustrated: “We will get a dozen approaches in a week and the overwhelming majority open with the product rather than with anything we recognise as a problem.”
He wants vendors to demonstrate a genuine customer need, acknowledge their product’s limitations and engage with engineers rather than relying on repeated sales follow-ups.
“Nine follow ups in a fortnight does not make us more likely to buy, it makes us certain we never will.”
The implications extend beyond vendor recruitment. Omdia’s Ball argues that the value partners provide is shifting away from selecting and stitching together disparate products towards orchestrating technology, delivering services and demonstrating measurable customer outcomes.
For MSPs, that means the next competitive advantage may not come from having the broadest security portfolio, but from knowing exactly which technologies deserve a place in it – and being prepared to remove those that don’t.